INSIGHTS & LEGAL COMMENTARY / SZADURSKI LAW

No Doubling Down: Staying Duplicative Provincial Offences Act Charges

Two matching document folders, one secured with a lavender band.

Under the Kienapple principle, a defendant cannot be convicted of multiple offences arising from the same facts when there is a factual and legal nexus between them. In Ontario, this can lead to duplicative charges under the Provincial Offences Act (POA) being stayed, which means they are ignored when fines are set. In regulatory prosecutions, that can substantially reduce the total fine imposed.

Key Takeaways

  • Provincial Offences Act charges under statutes like the Occupational Health and Safety Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, Technical Standards and Safety Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 16, and Environmental Protection Act are strict liability offences with few substantive defences.
  • Procedural strategy therefore plays a large role in POA defence.
  • The Kienapple principle bars multiple convictions where there is a factual and legal nexus between the charges.
  • Stayed charges are not counted when a court determines fines.
  • In Fujitec, staying two of five counts likely saved the defendant roughly $200,000 in fines.

What Are Provincial Offences Act Charges?

In my commercial and employment litigation practice, I regularly see Ontario business owners facing serious charges under the POA. These charges usually come from breaching the offences provisions of statutes such as:

  • the Occupational Health and Safety Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1;
  • the Technical Standards and Safety Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 16;
  • the Planning Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.13; and,
  • the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.19.

Breaching these statutes can lead to hefty fines for individuals and corporations, and even jail for individual defendants. Because these are strict liability offences, true substantive defences are rare. Defending POA charges therefore often depends on procedural strategy more than on any substantive defence.

How Can Duplicative Charges Be Stayed?

One important strategy is to analyze the charges carefully, where more than one has been laid, to see whether any are duplicative because they stem from the same facts. If a defendant can show this, the duplicative charges can be stayed under the Kienapple principle. Stayed charges are ignored when the court determines the applicable fines, which can significantly reduce the cumulative fines imposed on a party found guilty.

What Is the Kienapple Principle?

Many procedural strategies in POA defence come from Canadian criminal law, including the Kienapple principle. It comes from the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Kienapple v. R., 1974 CanLII 14 (SCC), [1975] 1 SCR 729.

In that criminal case, the accused was convicted of two offences arising from the same incident. The question on appeal was whether he could be convicted of both when they stemmed from the same facts. The Court held that he could not. A person should be punished only once where only one wrong has occurred, and only one wrong exists where there is both a factual and a legal nexus between the offences.

How Does Kienapple Work in POA Cases? The Fujitec Decision

The Technical Standards and Safety Authority v. Fujitec, 2013 ONSC 497, shows how the principle works in a regulatory prosecution. The case involved a failed elevator that injured five people. Fujitec was charged with five counts under the Technical Standards and Safety Act and Ontario Regulation 209/01 (Elevating Devices):

  1. Count 1: failing to inspect and examine the parts and functions of an elevating device at regular intervals;
  2. Count 2: failing to repair or replace worn or defective components to keep the device safe;
  3. Count 3: failing to ensure the device was in a safe operating condition;
  4. Count 4: failing to maintain a log book with up-to-date data; and
  5. Count 5: causing or permitting the device to be operated in an unsafe condition.

Which Counts Were Stayed?

At trial, Justice Young stayed Count 3 in favour of Count 2, and Count 2 in favour of Count 1. In substance, Counts 2 and 3 were too closely tied to Count 1 by their factual and legal nexus. Fujitec could not be fined for all three, even though it was clearly guilty of each. These stays were not contested on appeal.

Why Was Count 5 Not Stayed?

On appeal, the issue was Justice Young’s refusal to stay Count 5 as having a factual and legal nexus to Count 1. Justice Pollak clarified that Count 1 was a failure to inspect the elevator to ensure it was safe. Count 5 was the more serious charge of putting the faulty elevator into service. With no factual and legal nexus between them, the fine for Count 5 was upheld.

What Fines Were Imposed?

  • $100,000 for Count 1
  • $30,000 for Count 4
  • $270,000 for Count 5
  • a 25% victim surcharge

Total fine: $500,000.

What Does Fujitec Mean for Defendants?

Fujitec shows how significant POA consequences can be. It also shows how valuable the Kienapple argument can be. Counts 2 and 3 were stayed with relative ease, and that argument likely saved Fujitec approximately $200,000 in fines. On the other hand, because Count 5 was not stayed, Fujitec paid its largest fine, $270,000.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Kienapple principle?
It is a rule that prevents multiple convictions for offences arising from the same facts where there is a factual and legal nexus between them.

Does Kienapple apply to Provincial Offences Act charges?
Yes. It is a procedural strategy borrowed from criminal law and applied in regulatory prosecutions, as in Fujitec.

What does it mean to stay a charge?
A stayed charge is not pursued to a penalty. The defendant is not fined for it, even if the court finds the underlying conduct occurred.

What is a factual and legal nexus?
It is a close connection between two charges, both in the underlying facts and in the legal elements of the offences. If either is missing, a stay may not be available.

Can I be fined separately for multiple POA counts?
Yes, where the counts are genuinely distinct.

Are there many defences to POA charges?
Few substantive ones. Procedural strategies like Kienapple are therefore especially important.

Get Experienced Counsel for Provincial Offences Defence

When facing POA charges of any kind, it is crucial to have counsel who understand the defences and strategies available, including when and how the Kienapple principle applies. At Szadurski Law, we defend businesses and individuals facing OHSA, TSSA, environmental, and other regulatory charges under the Provincial Offences Act. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your charges.

Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.

Legal Disclaimer

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice. Reading, sharing, or interacting with this blog does not establish an attorney-client relationship. If you require legal counsel, please consult with a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction to address your specific situation.