Under section 15 of Ontario’s Regulatory Modernization Act, 2007 (RMA), courts can consider a defendant’s prior convictions under the same or any other Provincial Act when sentencing for an Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) offence. A prior record, even under a different statute, can be a significant aggravating factor. OHSA prosecutions and other regulatory matters are prosecuted under Ontario’s Provincial Offences Act (POA), so a conviction in one area can affect sentencing in another.
Key Takeaways
- Section 15 of the RMA allows courts to consider prior convictions under the same or another Act.
- Prior convictions under any provincial regulatory statute, such as the Technical Safety and Standards Act or the Environmental Protection Act, can be considered.
- OHSA convictions can result in significant fines and, in aggravated cases, jail for individuals.
- In R. v. Lootawan and Haniff, six prior environmental convictions were treated as a significant aggravating factor.
- Employers with prior provincial offences convictions should seek counsel before and during operations.
How Do Courts Sentence OHSA Convictions?
OHSA convictions frequently result in significant fines for both corporations and individuals. Individual defendants may also face jail where the breaches involve significant aggravating factors.
Sections 66(1) and (2) of the OHSA give courts wide discretion over whether to impose a fine, how large it should be, and when incarceration is justified. As in criminal law, courts follow the overarching principle of proportionality. They apply an approach tailored to the OHSA, guided by case law setting out mitigating and aggravating factors ,discussed in a previous blog in this series. These regulatory matters proceed under the Provincial Offences Act, which governs how provincial offences are prosecuted and defended in Ontario.
Can Prior Regulatory Convictions Increase an OHSA Sentence?
Yes. In addition to the factors developed in the case law, section 15 of the RMA gives courts statutory authority to consider prior regulatory convictions when sentencing for an OHSA offence.
Section 15(1) applies when a person convicted of an offence has previously been convicted of an offence under the same or another Act. Courts can therefore weigh convictions under any provincial regulatory regime. Many provincial statutes have offence provisions, including the Technical Safety and Standards Act and the Environmental Protection Act.
How Have Courts Applied Section 15 of the RMA?
Case law is limited. Section 15 has typically been used to highlight multiple earlier OHSA convictions when sentencing for a new OHSA conviction.
An unpublished decision, R. v. T. Lootawan and A. Haniff (2014, OCJ), shows a broader use. The court sentenced an individual defendant to 45 days in jail and a $2,000 fine. Relying on section 15 of the RMA, it treated the defendant’s six prior convictions under the Environmental Protection Act as a significant aggravating factor.
The court emphasized that the defendant’s pattern of detrimental behaviour mattered more than her outstanding fines. In its view, the pattern showed a serious disregard for public welfare statutes and the consequences of her actions.
What Does This Mean for Ontario Employers?
Lootawan is a stern reminder for Ontario employers subject to the OHSA, which covers most employers. Courts typically consider regulatory history when sentencing. The court in Lootawan also recognized that section 15(1) reinforces its authority to consider convictions under any provincial regulatory framework.
Employers should therefore treat their whole regulatory record as relevant to OHSA exposure, particularly if they or their associates have prior provincial offences convictions. Seeking qualified counsel before and during operations covered by the OHSA is a sound way to manage that risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can past convictions affect my OHSA sentence?
Yes. Section 15 of the RMA allows courts to consider prior convictions under the same or another Act when sentencing.
Do prior convictions have to be OHSA convictions?
No. Convictions under other provincial statutes, such as the Environmental Protection Act or the Technical Safety and Standards Act, amongst many others, can be considered.
What was R. v. Lootawan and Haniff?
An unpublished 2014 Ontario Court of Justice decision in which an individual received 45 days in jail and a $2,000 fine, with six prior Environmental Protection Act convictions treated as a significant aggravating factor.
Can someone go to jail for an OHSA conviction?
Individuals can, particularly where significant aggravating factors, such as a poor regulatory record, are present.
Which law governs OHSA prosecutions in Ontario?
OHSA charges and other regulatory matters are prosecuted under the Provincial Offences Act, while the OHSA sets the offences and penalties.
Get Help With OHSA Compliance and Regulatory Defence
If you or your business need help maintaining OHSA compliance or defending regulatory charges under the Provincial Offences Act, we are available to help. At Szadurski Law, we advise and represent employers and individuals in OHSA and other regulatory matters. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.