Officially Induced Error (OIE) is a rarely successful defence to charges under Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA). It applies where a defendant breached the Act because an appropriate official told them they were compliant, and their reliance on that advice was reasonable. The same defence applies to charges under other statutes prosecuted under Ontario’s Provincial Offences Act (POA), including the Technical Standards and Safety Act, 2000 (TSSA) and the Environmental Protection Act.
Key Takeaways
- OIE is the only substantive defence to an established OHSA breach apart from due diligence defence.
- OIE also applies to charges under other statutes falling under the Provincial Offences Act.
- It is rarely successful and often misunderstood.
- OIE is separate from the mistaken fact branch of due diligence, though the two are often conflated.
- The Supreme Court of Canada’s six-part test in Lévis (City) v. Tétreault governs the defence.
- Reasonableness of both the official’s advice and the defendant’s reliance on it are the most important factors.
- Employers must proactively maintain compliance, because reliance that was once reasonable can stop being reasonable.
What Is Officially Induced Error?
OHSA breaches carry potentially significant consequences for both companies and individuals, and substantive defences are very limited. Many assume due diligence is the only one. There is a second: officially induced error.
OIE says a defendant may have breached the OHSA but still cannot be convicted because an official told them they were compliant when the breach occurred. The breach was therefore not technically the defendant’s fault.
Courts have described OIE as a rare exception to the maxim ignorantia juris non excusat (ignorance of the law is no excuse).
Does OIE Apply to Other Provincial Offences Act Charges?
Yes. OHSA charges are prosecuted under the Provincial Offences Act, which also governs charges under many other provincial regulatory statutes, such as the TSSA and the Planning Act. The OIE defence is not limited to the OHSA. It is a general defence to regulatory offences, so a defendant charged under any statute falling under the POA may be able to rely on it where the elements are met. Each statute has its own wording and the facts of each case matter, but the same test applies.
How Is OIE Different From Due Diligence?
The case law often conflates OIE with the first branch of due diligence, the mistaken fact defence. That is understandable, since both involve a defendant arguing it mistakenly believed it was following the law. Appellate courts have made clear, however, that OIE is a standalone defence that is related to, but separate from, the due diligence analysis.
What Is the Test for Officially Induced Error?
The Supreme Court of Canada set out the test for regulatory offences in Lévis (City) v. Tétreault; Lévis (City) v. 2629-4470 Québec inc., 2006 SCC 12. The defendant must establish that:
- an error of law, or of mixed law and fact, was made;
- the defendant assessed the legal consequences of their actions;
- the advice came from an appropriate official;
- the advice was reasonable;
- the advice was erroneous; and
- the defendant relied on the advice in committing the breach.
Courts have adopted this test and treat the most important step as an objective assessment of whether both the official’s advice and the defendant’s reliance on it were reasonable.
What Did Ontario v. Sunrise Propane Decide?
Ontario v. Sunrise Propane Energy Group Inc., 2018 ONCA 461, shows what does not qualify as a valid OIE defence.
The facts. A Technical Standards and Safety Authority inspector visited the defendant’s worksite for a compliance visit. A Director’s Public Safety Order had been made prohibiting truck-to-truck propane transfers, subject to certain exemptions. The order was posted to the Technical Standards and Safety Authority website after the inspector’s visit. As the inspector left, an employee asked, “Can we continue operating?” and the inspector replied, “Yes.” About a year later, a series of explosions occurred at the worksite, caused by truck-to-truck propane transfers.
The inspector’s evidence. At trial, the inspector testified that his “yes” referred only to other propane transfer practices, not truck-to-truck transfers.
The court’s reasoning. Despite this, the court suggested that reliance on the inspector’s “yes” may have been enough to ground an OIE defence initially. However, continued reliance after the order was posted to the Technical Standards and Safety Authority’s website was not reasonable. The defendant did not follow up after the posting and did not apply for an exemption from the prohibition.
What Does This Mean for Ontario Employers?
OIE can be a powerful defence when the facts support it. Sunrise Propane highlights the key principle: reasonableness. A defendant must prove it reasonably relied on reasonable advice from an appropriate official. Interestingly, such reliance may be valid even where the advice was given in passing as an inspector was leaving a worksite.
But compliance is an ongoing responsibility. Employers need to seek out information proactively to stay compliant under the OHSA and other regulatory statutes, or they may be left with no defence at all.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is OIE?
It is a defence under which a defendant who breached a regulatory statute can avoid conviction because an appropriate official gave erroneous advice that the defendant reasonably relied on.
Is officially induced error the same as the mistaken fact defence?
No. They are often conflated, but OIE is a separate defence from the mistaken fact branch of due diligence.
What must a defendant prove for OIE?
The six elements from Lévis, including that the advice came from an appropriate official, was reasonable but erroneous, and was relied on in committing the breach.
Is an inspector’s casual comment enough?
It can be, according to Sunrise Propane, but reliance must remain reasonable over time, and later developments can end that reasonableness.
Does OIE apply to charges under other statutes falling under the Provincial Offences Act?
Yes. It is a general defence to regulatory offences, so it can apply to charges under statutes such as the Technical Standards and Safety Act and the Environmental Protection Act, as well as the OHSA.
Is not knowing the law a defence?
Almost never. OIE is the rare exception.
Get Experienced Counsel for OHSA and Provincial Offences Defence
Whether you want to maintain compliance or assess whether you have grounds to defend a breach, qualified counsel can help you use every legal tool available. At Szadurski Law, we advise and defend employers and individuals facing OHSA charges and charges under other statutes falling under the Provincial Offences Act. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.