When a court sentences a defendant under Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA), it weighs aggravating and mitigating factors to arrive at a proportionate and deterrent penalty. A similar sentencing approach is commonly applied to other charges prosecuted under Ontario’s Provincial Offences Act (POA). Corporations can face fines of up to $2,000,000 per offence under the OHSA, and individuals can face jail time. Understanding sentencing factors is critical to building a strong defence.
Key Takeaways
- Section 66(1) of the OHSA gives courts broad discretion in sentencing.
- Maximum penalties are per offence, and prosecutions often involve multiple offences.
- Courts rarely impose the maximum, but fines for egregious breaches are steadily rising.
- The factors from R. v. Cotton Felts Ltd. remain the foundation of OHSA sentencing.
- The same proportionality and deterrence analysis generally applies to other regulatory charges under the Provincial Offences Act, adapted to the statute and facts.
- Courts may disregard the parties’ submissions and impose any fine they consider justified.
What Are the Penalties for OHSA Convictions in Ontario?
Section 66(1) of the OHSA gives the court broad discretion to punish breaches of the statute. Current maximum penalties are:
- Corporations: fines of up to $2,000,000, with significant minimum fines for subsequent breaches
- Individuals: fines of up to $500,000 and/or up to 12 months in jail
- Directors or officers of corporations: fines of up to $1,500,000 and/or up to 12 months in jail
These figures apply per offence, and defendants often face multiple offences at once. Courts rarely impose the maximum. However, for egregious breaches, large companies are regularly fined approximately $100,000 to $300,000 per offence, and individuals have often received jail sentences of one to three months. Maximum fines continue to increase as the OHSA is amended regularly.
How Do Courts Determine an OHSA Sentence?
To set the amount of a fine or the length of any jail sentence, the court looks to case law for aggravating and mitigating factors specific to the defendant and the breaches before it. These factors guide the proportionality assessment the court must complete before imposing any punishment.
What Did R. v. Cotton Felts Ltd. Establish?
The factors were established in the leading decision of R. v. Cotton Felts Ltd., 1982 CanLII 3695 (ON CA). The Court of Appeal pointed to considerations including:
- the size of the company involved;
- the scope of the economic activity at issue;
- the extent of actual and potential harm to the public; and
- the maximum penalty prescribed by statute.
Most importantly, Cotton Felts emphasized that the court’s duty is to impose a penalty that serves as general deterrence for all companies subject to the OHSA. The decision also confirms that a court may set aside the parties’ submissions entirely and impose any fine it considers justified. In that case, the court imposed a fine ten times the amount proposed by the Crown.
What Other Factors Do Courts Consider?
Later OHSA and POA decisions have expanded on the Cotton Felts factors. Courts also consider, among other things:
- the defendant’s previous regulatory history;
- any remorse shown, or lack of it; and
- the general seriousness of the offences and the defendant’s behaviour.
Do These Sentencing Factors Apply to Other Provincial Offences Act Charges?
Yes, in general. OHSA charges are prosecuted under the Provincial Offences Act, which is the procedural framework for a wide range of provincial regulatory offences in Ontario. These include charges pursuant to environmental, employment standards, building and fire safety, bylaw breaches, and other regulatory statutes.
Although each statute sets its own maximum penalties, courts sentencing regulatory offences commonly rely on the same core principles: proportionality, general deterrence, the size and resources of the defendant, the harm caused or risked, regulatory history, and remorse. The factors are adapted to the purpose of the statute and the facts of the case, but the analysis is similar.
For defendants, this means a strong sentencing strategy matters on any provincial offences charge, not just under the OHSA. Highlighting mitigating factors and understanding what the court will treat as aggravating can significantly affect the outcome.
Why Do Sentencing Factors Matter for Your Defence?
A conviction can have severe consequences. For small companies, it can mean bankruptcy or significant staff terminations. For individuals, it can mean jail time. Although the court may impose a sentence regardless of what the parties submit, presenting the strongest possible case by fully and clearly highlighting mitigating factors is essential. It can mean the difference between a manageable fine and a penalty that is financially debilitating or personally traumatic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the maximum fine for an OHSA conviction in Ontario?
Corporations face fines of up to $2,000,000 per offence, directors and officers up to $1,500,000, and individuals up to $500,000. Individuals, directors, and officers may also face up to 12 months in jail.
Do courts usually impose the maximum fine?
Rarely. However, large companies are regularly fined approximately $100,000 to $300,000 per offence for egregious breaches.
Can someone go to jail under the OHSA?
Yes. Individuals, directors, and officers face up to 12 months in jail, and individuals have often received sentences of one to three months for serious breaches.
What are mitigating and aggravating factors in an OHSA sentence?
Examples include a clean regulatory history and genuine remorse. Aggravating factors include a flippant attitude, prior breaches, the seriousness of the conduct, and the harm caused.
Do these sentencing factors apply to other Provincial Offences Act charges?
Generally, yes. Courts commonly apply similar principles, such as proportionality, deterrence, regulatory history, and remorse, to other regulatory offences under the POA adjusted to the statute and facts.
Can a judge impose a higher fine than the Crown requests?
Yes. Under Cotton Felts, the court is not bound by the parties’ submissions.
Get Experienced Help With OHSA and POA Defence
Prudent employers seek qualified counsel throughout their business ventures to ensure they comply with the OHSA and other regulatory statutes. If you are facing a prosecution, experienced counsel can help you navigate a complex and often stressful process. At Szadurski Law, we advise businesses and individuals on OHSA compliance and defence, as well as other provincial offences matters. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.