The main substantive defence to a charge under Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) is due diligence. OHSA prosecutions and other regulatory defence matters fall under Ontario’s Provincial Offences Act (POA), which sets out the procedure for provincial offences. To succeed on a due diligence defence, the defendant must prove that it took every precaution reasonable in the circumstances, but the offence happened despite their efforts. Courts do not expect perfection, but the threshold is high, and the defence depends heavily on the facts.
Key Takeaways
- OHSA charges and other regulatory charges are prosecuted under the Provincial Offences Act.
- OHSA breaches, like many other regulatory offences, are strict liability offences.
- Strict liability limits the substantive defences available to a defendant.
- Due diligence is the main substantive defence, supported by procedural defences and strategies.
- Due diligence has two branches: 1. mistaken fact and 2. all reasonable steps.
- Courts do not require superhuman or perfect efforts, but the defendant carries a high burden.
How Does the Provincial Offences Act Relate to OHSA Charges?
In Ontario, OHSA charges and many other regulatory defence matters fall under the Provincial Offences Act, which governs how provincial offences are commenced, prosecuted, and defended. The same framework applies to many other regulatory statutes, including those covering environmental, employment standards, zoning bylaws, and building and fire safety matters. Each statute sets its own offences and penalties, but the strict liability principles and the due diligence defence discussed below apply broadly across regulatory prosecutions.
What Is a Strict Liability Offence?
Breaches of the OHSA, along with those of many other statutes, are strict liability offences. A defendant charged with one has limited substantive defences with which to prove its innocence.
Besides procedural defences and strategies, which should not be understated, and the often-unsuccessful defence of “officially induced error” (to be covered later in this series), the main substantive defence is due diligence.
What Is the Due Diligence Defence Under the OHSA?
Section 66(3) of the OHSA provides that, on a prosecution for failing to comply with subsection 23(1), clause 25(1)(b), (c) or (d), or subsection 27(1), it is a defence for the accused to prove that every precaution reasonable in the circumstances was taken.
Courts have interpreted this section as making the due diligence defence available for strict liability breaches of the OHSA and its regulations.
What Test Did the Supreme Court of Canada Set?
In R. v. City of Sault Ste. Marie (1978), the Supreme Court of Canada described the defence of due diligence as available:
- if the accused reasonably believed in a mistaken set of facts which, if true, would render the act or omission innocent; or
- if the accused took all reasonable steps to avoid the particular event.
What Is the Mistaken Fact Defence?
The first branch asserts that the defendant honestly and reasonably believed it was complying with the provisions at issue. It should not be confused with a defendant simply not knowing it was breaking the law, because ignorance of the law is almost never a valid defence. The mistaken fact defence is rarely successful because it requires a highly nuanced set of facts.
What Does “All Reasonable Steps” Mean?
The second branch is the heart of the due diligence defence. It says that although the provisions were breached, the defendant took every reasonable precaution to avoid the breach, and the breach happened despite its best efforts.
The threshold is high, and the defendant must prove it. However, the courts have made clear that defendants are not expected to be superhuman or perfect in their due diligence efforts. Defending OHSA and other regulatory charges on this ground is therefore possible when it is done correctly.
Why Is Due Diligence So Fact-Driven?
The defence requires detailed knowledge of the law, the parties involved, and prevailing industry standards. The stakes are high. As provincial offences, OHSA convictions can lead to very large fines for corporations and individuals, and individuals convicted of serious charges can and do receive jail sentences.
Frequently Asked Questions
What law governs OHSA charges in Ontario?
OHSA offences are prosecuted under Ontario’s Provincial Offences Act, as are many other regulatory offences. The OHSA itself sets out the offences and penalties.
What is a strict liability offence?
It is an offence where the prosecution does not need to prove intent, but the defendant may avoid conviction by proving it took reasonable care. OHSA breaches are strict liability offences.
What is the due diligence defence under the OHSA?
It is a defence under section 66(3) and the case law, allowing a defendant to avoid conviction by proving it took every precaution reasonable in the circumstances.
Does the due diligence defence apply to other Provincial Offences Act charges?
Generally, yes. Due diligence is the main substantive defence to strict liability regulatory offences, though each statute’s wording and the facts of the case matter.
What is the mistaken fact defence?
It applies where the defendant reasonably believed in a mistaken set of facts that, if true, would have made its conduct innocent. It is rarely successful.
Is not knowing the law a defence to an OHSA charge?
Almost never. The mistaken fact defence is different from ignorance of the law.
Does due diligence require perfection?
No. Courts do not expect superhuman or perfect efforts, but the defendant must prove it took all reasonable steps.
Can someone go to jail for an OHSA conviction?
Yes. Individuals convicted of serious charges can and do receive jail sentences, in addition to large fines.
Get Experienced Counsel for OHSA and Provincial Offences Defence
Defending an OHSA or other provincial offences charge is not something to take lightly. It calls for counsel experienced in regulatory defence. At Szadurski Law, we defend businesses and individuals facing OHSA and other regulatory charges under the Provincial Offences Act. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your charges.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.