In Canada, a wrongfully dismissed employee is generally entitled to damages that include variable compensation they would have earned during the reasonable notice period, unless removed validly via contract. Bonuses, commissions, and equity incentives can substantially increase a termination payout. Entitlements arising from a genuine shareholder relationship, however, are treated differently from employment entitlements.
Key Takeaways
- Without a valid termination clause, common law reasonable notice damages generally include bonuses and incentive pay.
- Under Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition, plan language must clearly and unambiguously remove common law entitlements.
- Shareholder rights under a properly separate agreement are generally not treated as employment compensation.
- Courts look at the substance of an arrangement, not just its label.
What Is Variable Compensation?
Variable compensation is pay that is not a fixed salary. It commonly includes annual bonuses, commissions, profit sharing, long-term incentive plans (LTIPs), stock options, and restricted share units. For executives and sales professionals, it can make up a large share of total compensation (often the majority of compensation), which makes its treatment on termination critical.
How Do Courts Treat Bonuses and Incentives After Dismissal?
Where an employee is dismissed without a valid termination clause, the employer owes damages for the reasonable notice period. The goal is to put the employee in the position they would have been in had they worked through that period. This includes compensation they would have earned during it, not just base salary.
The Supreme Court of Canada in Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, set out a two-step approach to assess variable compensation entitlements upon termination of employment:
- Would the employee have received the benefit but for the dismissal? If so, the employee is presumptively entitled to damages for it.
- Does a contract or plan unambiguously remove that entitlement? Language requiring “active employment” is generally not enough. The wording must clearly take away the common law right and cover the termination context.
In Matthews, the employee recovered a significant long-term incentive payout despite plan language conditioning it on active employment, because the language did not clearly exclude damages during the notice period.
What About Employment Standards Legislation?
Statutory minimums are narrower than common law damages. Under Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000, non-discretionary bonuses and commissions that form part of regular compensation can count toward statutory termination entitlements, while purely discretionary bonuses generally do not. Employers cannot contract below these minimums, and a clause that attempts to do so may be void.
Employment Entitlements vs. Shareholder Entitlements
The distinction between these two categories is important in this area.
Employment entitlements are compensation earned because of the work relationship, such as bonuses, commissions, and equity grants awarded as part of the compensation package. Courts treat these as damages items in a wrongful dismissal.
Shareholder entitlements arise because a person owns shares and holds rights under a shareholder or share purchase agreement. These rights come from the investment, not the job. If an agreement is genuinely separate from the employment contract, the employee’s rights to the shares, and any buyback terms, are generally governed by that agreement rather than by termination pay principles.
In Mikelsteins v. Morrison Hershfield Limited, 2021 ONCA 155, the Court of Appeal for Ontario found that an employee’s rights under a separate share purchase arrangement did not form part of the termination pay calculation. The agreement’s terms governed those rights.
Practical Tips
Employers: Draft incentive and equity plans with clear, express language addressing termination, and document genuine share ownership separately. Ambiguity is read against the employer (if they are the drafter). Also, confirm that any termination clause is valid, since an invalid one reopens common law damages, including variable pay.
Employees: Do not assume that unvested bonuses or equity are lost on termination. Have your contract and plan documents reviewed before accepting a severance offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I claim a bonus after being terminated without cause in Canada?
Often yes, for the portion you would have earned during the reasonable notice period, unless a valid, clear contract term removes the entitlement.
Does “active employment” language remove my entitlement?
Not necessarily. Under Matthews, the language must clearly and unambiguously remove common law damages.
Are share entitlements part of termination pay?
Generally, not if they arise under a genuinely separate shareholder arrangement, but courts look at substance over form.
Get Advice on Variable Compensation and Termination
Variable pay disputes are fact-specific and often involve significant sums. At Szadurski Law, we advise employers and employees on termination entitlements, incentive plans, and executive compensation. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to review your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.