Federally regulated employees have rights to both “Unjust Dismissal” under section 240 of the Canada Labour Code (CLC). They also have rights to “Wrongful Dismissal” at common law, if their termination clause is invalid (it usually is). An Unjust Dismissal complaint generally requires 12 months of continuous service, no collective agreement, a filing within 90 days of dismissal, and no contemporaneous claim for lost wages or entitlements under the CLC. Unlike federal employees, provincial non-unionized employees generally only have rights to Wrongful Dismissal if their termination clause is invalid (they often are but not as often as federal employees).
I am seeing more and more clients who come to me for a second opinion and were never told by their previous counsel that, as federal workers, they have Unjust Dismissal rights in addition to Wrongful Dismissal rights. Missing this option can mean missing a short deadline and the most powerful remedies available. In other lawyers’ defence, Unjust Dismissal is just not a well known area.
I will be the first to admit that, due to some limitations of the Unjust Dismissal regime beyond this blog, it is not often a great option for the employee. However, there are many cases that fit the Unjust Dismissal parameters well and should be explored with this in mind.
Key Takeaways
- Federal employees may have both Unjust Dismissal rights and Wrongful Dismissal rights at common law, depending on the facts.
- An Unjust Dismissal complaint must generally be filed within 90 days of dismissal.
- Eligibility requires 12 consecutive months of continuous employment and no collective agreement ,amongst other requirements.
- Unlike Wrongful Dismissal claims, Unjust Dismissal can lead to reinstatement as a default remedy.
- Employees laid off for discontinuance of a function, or who are “true” managers are exempt from Unjust Dismissal protections.
What Is Unjust Dismissal Under Section 240 of the CLC?
Section 240 allows eligible federal employees to complain that they were dismissed unjustly, if terminated without “Just Cause.” Federally regulated employers include airlines, banks, telecommunications companies, some Indigenous services, and interprovincial trucking companies. In Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., 2016 SCC 29, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that, subject to specific exemptions, federally regulated employers cannot dismiss employees without Just Cause by simply paying severance. If a federally regulated employee is terminated without Just Cause, they can be entitled to years of lost wages and/or reinstatement.
What Are the Requirements for an Unjust Dismissal Complaint?
An employee must generally show, amongst other things, that they:
- work for a federally regulated employer;
- have completed 12 consecutive months of continuous employment;
- are not subject to a collective agreement;
- were dismissed, which can include constructive dismissal in appropriate cases; and
- filed a written complaint within 90 days of the dismissal.
Who Is Exempt From Unjust Dismissal Protection?
Several groups cannot use s. 240:
- Employees with less than 12 months of continuous employment
- Unionized employees covered by a collective agreement, who use the grievance process instead
- Employees laid off due to discontinuance of a function, if done so in good faith.
- “Managers” as defined by the CLC. However, the courts have interpreted this exemption very strictly.
Due to these exemptions, it is very common for federally regulated employees to be labeled as “managers” erroneously and/or being terminated for alleged “discontinuance” of function when in fact the role just shifted. These circumstances often do not meet the exemptions and are what the case law is largely centered around.
What Is Wrongful Dismissal at Common Law?
At common law, employers must give reasonable notice of termination or pay in lieu. If an employee’s contract does not validly limit entitlements to statutory minimums, the employee can claim reasonable-notice damages based on age, length of service, character of employment, and availability of similar work. The remedy is financial and almost never includes reinstatement.
Federal employees are not shut out of this claim. If the facts allow, they can also pursue Wrongful Dismissal at common law as well as Unjust Dismissal under the CLC. Strategy, timing, and the risk of overlapping recovery need careful attention, so advice early is essential.
How Do the Two Regimes Compare?
| Unjust dismissal (CLC s. 240) | Wrongful dismissal (common law) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who it applies to | Federally regulated, non-unionized employees with 12+ months of service | Federal and provincial non-unionized employees, depending on the facts |
| Deadline | 90 days | Provincial limitation period (generally two years in Ontario) |
| Key question | Was the dismissal just? | Was reasonable notice given? |
| Main remedy | Compensation or reinstatement | Damages in lieu of notice |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can federal employees be fired without cause in Canada?
Generally not unless the dismissal is just. After Wilson, paying severance alone does not make a dismissal lawful.
Do federal employees have both Unjust Dismissal and Wrongful Dismissal rights?
Yes, if the facts allow. The two regimes are distinct, but neither automatically excludes the other.
How long do I have to file an Unjust Dismissal complaint?
Generally 90 days from the date of dismissal.
Can I seek reinstatement in an Unjust Dismissal Claim?
Yes, reinstatement is available for a successful Unjust Dismissal claimant. However, it is rarely sought and compensation in lieu of reinstatement is chosen instead.
Get Advice on Federal and Provincial Dismissal Rights
Because the deadline is short, seek advice immediately after termination. At Szadurski Law, we advise employees and employers on dismissals under the CLC and at common law. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to review your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.