INSIGHTS & LEGAL COMMENTARY / SZADURSKI LAW

Restrictive Covenants in Canada and Ontario: What Employers and Employees Need to Know

Employment contract folder with a loosened lavender ribbon and pen.

Restrictive covenants in Canada are enforceable only when they are reasonable, and courts scrutinize them closely in employment. In Ontario, most non-compete clauses have been prohibited since October 25th, 2021, but have been de facto invalid for even longer. Employers who wrongfully dismiss an employee also generally cannot rely on that employee’s restrictive covenants.

Key Takeaways

  • Covenants must protect a legitimate business interest and be reasonable.
  • Ontario bans most employee non-competes, with limited exceptions.
  • Non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses remain enforceable if well drafted.
  • Wrongful dismissal generally frees the employee from restrictive covenants.

What Are Restrictive Covenants in Employment?

Restrictive covenants are contract terms that limit what an employee can do after employment ends. The most common are:

  • Non-competition clauses, which prevent working for a competitor or starting a competing business
  • Non-solicitation clauses, which prevent soliciting the employer’s clients or employees
  • Confidentiality clauses, which protect trade secrets and sensitive information

How Do Canadian Courts Decide Whether a Covenant Is Enforceable?

Because restrictive covenants limit a person’s ability to earn a living, courts treat them as restraints of trade. The employer must show the covenant is reasonable. Courts generally ask whether:

  • the employer has a legitimate proprietary interest, such as client relationships or confidential information;
  • the duration, geography, and scope of the restriction are no broader than necessary; and
  • the wording is clear and unambiguous.

In Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC 6, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that courts will not rewrite or “read down” an ambiguous or overbroad covenant in an employment contract. If the clause is unreasonable, it fails entirely. Courts apply a more lenient standard in the sale of a business, as explained in Payette v. Guay inc., 2013 SCC 45, because the parties bargain on more equal footing. Courts also prefer non-solicitation clauses to non-competes, since they protect the employer in a less restrictive way.

Are Non-Compete Agreements Enforceable in Ontario?

Generally, no. Under the Working for Workers Act, 2021, Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 prohibits employers from entering into non-compete agreements with employees. There are generally two exceptions:

  • Sale of a business, where the seller becomes an employee of the purchaser immediately after the sale
  • Executives, including chief executive officers, presidents, chief financial officers, and other “chief” executive roles

The ban applies to agreements made on or after October 25th, 2021, so older non-competes are still assessed under the common law. Outside Ontario, most provinces continue to apply the common law reasonableness test.

What About Non-Solicitation and Confidentiality Clauses?

The ban does not cover these clauses, so they remain enforceable if reasonable. A clause restricting solicitation of clients the employee actually dealt with, for a modest period, is far more likely to be upheld than one covering every client indefinitely. Senior employees may also owe fiduciary duties to the employer that exist apart from any contract.

It is important that a non-solicitation clause does not try to “hide” a non-competition clause within it.

Can an Employer Enforce Restrictive Covenants After a Wrongful Dismissal?

Generally, no. If an employer wrongfully dismisses an employee, it usually cannot rely on that employee’s restrictive covenants. Canadian courts follow the long-standing rule from General Billposting Co. v. Atkinson, [1909] AC 118 (HL): an employer who wrongfully terminates an employee repudiates the contract and releases the employee from obligations like non-competition and non-solicitation.

In practice, an employer that terminates without proper notice or pay, or relies on an invalid termination clause, may lose the ability to enforce the covenant. An employer cannot breach the contract and then insist on its benefits. Employers should treat covenant enforceability as part of the termination decision, since paying the correct entitlements may be what preserves their protection. Separate equitable duties to protect confidential information may still apply.

Practical Tips

Employers: Draft covenants narrowly and tie them to a specific business interest. Avoid ambiguity, since courts will not fix it. Confirm whether Ontario’s ban or an exception applies and terminate lawfully.

Employees: Review any covenant before signing and before joining a competitor. Get advice, since an unenforceable covenant is not always obvious.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are non-competes enforceable in Ontario?

Generally not for agreements made on or after October 25th, 2021, except in a sale of a business or for executives. Even then, they must be reasonable.

Will a court fix an overly broad covenant?

No. Under Shafron, courts will not rewrite an unreasonable employment covenant. This rule varies by province as well.

Can my employer enforce a non-compete after firing me?

Depends on whether the termination is deemed “wrongful.”

Get Practical Guidance on Restrictive Covenants

Whether you are experiencing a termination, drafting covenants, defending against enforcement, or planning a termination, the details matter. At Szadurski Law, we advise employers and employees on restrictive covenants, termination, and related disputes. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to protect your position.

Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.

Legal Disclaimer

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice. Reading, sharing, or interacting with this blog does not establish an attorney-client relationship. If you require legal counsel, please consult with a qualified attorney licensed in your jurisdiction to address your specific situation.