A non-unionized employee terminated without a valid termination clause is entitled to reasonable notice at common law. Ontario courts treat 24 months as the high end of that range, and only “exceptional circumstances” justify going beyond it. The leading cases show that long service, seniority, and age are not always enough on their own. However, the case law is starting to progress in this area.
Key Takeaways
- Reasonable notice is decided case by case generally using the Bardal factors: character of employment, length of service, age, and availability of similar employment.
- There is no absolute cap, but generally only exceptional circumstances support a notice period above 24 months.
- In Dawe v. Equitable Life, the Court of Appeal held that seniority, 37 years of service, and age were not exceptional.
- In Lynch v. Avaya and Milwid v. IBM, the Court of Appeal upheld awards of 30 and 27 months.
- The exceptional circumstances notice period cases turned on facts beyond the standard Bardal factors.
What Is Reasonable Notice at Common Law?
Absent just cause, an employer must give reasonable notice of termination or pay in lieu. If the employment contract does not validly limit the employee to statutory minimums, common law notice applies. The gap between the two can be very large, and this is the most litigated issue in non-unionized employment law.
How Do Courts Set Reasonable Notice?
Courts apply the Bardal factors from Bardal v. Globe & Mail Ltd. (1960). There is no formula, such as “one month per year of service”, so outcomes depend on the evidence.
What Is the 24-Month “Cap”?
In Lowndes v. Summit Ford Sales Ltd., 2006 CanLII 14 (ON CA), the Court of Appeal held that reasonable notice is case-specific. It said there is no absolute upper limit, but generally only exceptional circumstances will support a base notice period above 24 months.
What Does Dawe v. Equitable Life Tell Us About Exceptional Circumstances?
In Dawe v. The Equitable Life Insurance Company of Canada, 2019 ONCA 512, a 62-year-old Senior Vice President with 37 years of service was awarded 30 months at first instance. The Court of Appeal reduced it to 24 months.
What Did Lynch v. Avaya and Milwid v. IBM Add?
In October 2023, the Court of Appeal upheld two awards above 24 months.
Lynch v. Avaya Canada Corporation, 2023 ONCA 696 (30 months). Lynch was a professional engineer, nearly 64, with about 38 years of service. The Court identified these exceptional circumstances:
- his job was unique, designing software for hardware made at Avaya’s Belleville facility, and his skills were tailored to that workplace;
- he had developed one or two patents a year for Avaya;
- he had been identified as a “key performer”; and
- there was no comparable employment in Belleville, where he had lived throughout his career.
Milwid v. IBM Canada Ltd., 2023 ONCA 702 (27 months). Milwid was a 62-year-old manager with 38 years at IBM. The motion judge awarded 26 months on the Bardal factors, plus one month because he was dismissed at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic. The Court of Appeal found the following:
- relying on the unique combination of Bardal factors alongside other exceptional circumstances was not improper;
- his skills were not transferable because they related almost exclusively to IBM’s products; and
- the pandemic was a “truly exceptional circumstance” justifying the extra month.
The Court also stressed that judges should clearly identify the factors that make a case exceptional.
Many cases since 2020 (post-Dawe) have decided that exceptional circumstances existed, for a variety of reasons. This includes the principle that exceptional circumstances will exist if the termination at issue equates to a “forced retirement.”
What Is the Takeaway for Employees and Employers?
Dawe shows what does not work: age, seniority, and service alone, in many cases. Lynch and Milwid show what can work: evidence that the employee’s skills were highly specific to the employer, a very limited local job market, distinguishing performance and contributions, and unusual timing. Overall, it takes nuanced factors, unique to the employee at issue.
My prediction is that exceptional circumstances notice periods will continue to climb overtime as the economy consistently bounces up and down violently.
Employees: Gather evidence of how specialized your role was, what the job market looks like, your contributions, and any other factors unique to your circumstances.
Employers: A valid termination clause remains the best protection. Also consider how specialized and locally tied a long-serving employee is, and their chances of re-employing, before setting up a package.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a cap on reasonable notice in Ontario?
Not an absolute one, but only exceptional circumstances generally justify more than 24 months.
Do age and long service justify more than 24 months?
They can but usually not on their own. Dawe held that these factors are already reflected in a 24-month award.
What counts as exceptional circumstances?
Recent examples include highly employer-specific skills, no comparable local employment, a “key performer” record, dismissal at the outset of the pandemic, entire careers with one specific employer, and “forced retirement”.
Have courts awarded more than 24 months?
Yes. The Court of Appeal upheld 30 months in Lynch and 27 months in Milwid, amongst numerous other cases.
Get Advice on Reasonable Notice and Termination
Reasonable notice is highly fact-specific, and the amounts at stake can be significant. At Szadurski Law, we advise employees and employers on termination entitlements, severance packages, and wrongful dismissal claims. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to review your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.