Regulated professionals such as doctors, nurses, lawyers, and engineers can face two investigations at once: one by their employer and one by their governing college or society. The two processes run on separate tracks but affect each other. What is said in one can be used in the other, and an employer’s decisions can trigger a report to the regulator. Early, coordinated decisions matter for both employers and employees.
Key Takeaways
- A workplace investigation is run by the employer. A regulatory investigation is run by a professional college or society, such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario or the Law Society of Ontario.
- The two proceed independently, with different standards and consequences.
- Employers of regulated professionals may have mandatory reporting duties to the regulator.
- Regulated professionals generally must cooperate with their regulator, and failing to do so can be misconduct.
- Statements made in one process can be relied on in the other.
- Early legal advice helps both employers and employees avoid mistakes.
What Is a Workplace Investigation?
A workplace investigation is an employer’s fact-finding process following a complaint or concern, such as harassment, discrimination, patient or client complaints, or policy breaches. Its findings often determine whether discipline or termination for cause is justified. It is separate from any regulatory process, but its findings can end up in front of the regulator.
What Is a Professional Regulatory Investigation?
Professional regulators exist to protect the public. In Ontario, most health professions fall under the Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991, while lawyers are governed by the Law Society Act and other professions by their own statutes. A regulator can open an investigation after a complaint, a mandatory report from an employer or facility, or on its own initiative. Outcomes can include a caution, remedial training, restrictions on practice, suspension, or revocation of the license, and often a public finding.
What Should Employers Consider When Investigating a Regulated Professional?
- Check for reporting duties. Employers of regulated professionals may be required to report to the regulator, for example when a professional is terminated or disciplined for reasons such as professional misconduct, incompetence, or incapacity. Deadlines can be short.
- Do not trade silence for settlement. Mandatory reports cannot be bargained away, and threatening to report to gain leverage can create serious problems.
- Be fair and impartial. Give the employee the allegations and a genuine chance to respond. Use an external investigator for serious matters.
- Preserve evidence and protect privacy. Client or patient information may be subject to privacy legislation, so be careful about what is shared and with whom.
- Understand the difference in standards. A regulator’s finding does not automatically establish just cause for termination, and a workplace finding does not bind the regulator.
- Avoid reprisals against complainants and witnesses.
An unfair investigation can weaken an employer’s case for just cause and/or lead to other liabilities. So, it should be handled with care.
What Should Employees Consider in a Workplace Investigation?
- Take it seriously. Employees generally have a duty to participate, and refusing can itself be treated as misconduct.
- There are circumstances where not participating in an investigation is the right approach. However, these circumstances require careful legal advice.
- Know the allegations before responding.
- Get advice before your interview. Consider your regulatory exposure, since your answers can later be used by the regulator.
- Ask about a support person, and check whether your union or association can assist.
- Be accurate and consistent, and do not alter or destroy documents.
- Think ahead about reporting. The outcome of the investigation may trigger a mandatory report to your college.
What Should Regulated Professionals Consider in a Regulatory Investigation?
- Respond on time. Missing deadlines can lead to adverse findings or separate misconduct allegations.
- Cooperate, but with advice. Regulators have significant powers to require information, and a failure to cooperate can itself be misconduct. Speak with counsel before giving a written response or interview.
- Notify your insurer or protective association early, such as your professional liability insurer.
- Consider your employment. Check your contract for duties to inform your employer of regulatory proceedings.
- Be mindful of publicity. Many regulatory outcomes are public, which can affect your reputation and career.
- Do not contact the complainant to try to resolve the matter without advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be investigated by my employer and my college at the same time?
Yes. The processes are separate and can run in parallel, and statements in one may be used in the other.
Does my employer have to report me to my regulator?
Sometimes. Employers of some regulated professionals have mandatory reporting duties, particularly when a professional is terminated or disciplined for certain reasons. The rules vary by profession.
Can I refuse to answer my college’s questions?
Generally not without risk. Regulated professionals have a duty to cooperate, and refusing can lead to separate allegations.
Can I be fired because my college is investigating me?
It depends on the contract, the facts, and how essential the licence is to the role. An investigation alone does not necessarily justify cause for termination, so get advice.
Should I speak to a lawyer before responding?
Yes, ideally before responding to either your employer or your regulator.
Get Experienced Guidance on Investigations
Whether you are conducting an investigation or being investigated, the steps you take early often matter most. At Szadurski Law, we advise employers and regulated professionals on workplace investigations and the employment consequences of regulatory proceedings. Filip Szadurski is also a certified workplace investigator who offers third-party investigation services. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to discuss your situation.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.