A franchisor in Ontario can be held liable for a franchisee’s employees if it exerts too much control over the franchisee’s business. This can happen under the “related employer” doctrine in employment legislation and/or the “common employer” doctrine at common law. There is also similar risk if a franchisee themselves is found to be the franchisor’s employee rather than an contracting business. The more control a franchisor takes, the greater the risk.
Key Takeaways
- Under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) and the Labour Relations Act, 1995 (LRA), a franchisor may be found to be a “related employer” and share liability for statutory entitlements for a franchisee’s employees.
- At common law, a franchisor found to be a “common employer” may face far higher shared termination liability for a franchisee’s employees.
- Courts assess how much control the franchisor has over the franchisee’s work, pay, discipline, and hiring and firing, when determining related and/or common employer liability.
- A franchisee may, in rare cases, be found to be an employee of the franchisor.
Why Do Franchise and Employment Law Overlap in Ontario?
The intersection of franchise law and employment law receives little attention, yet ignoring it can expose franchisors to significant and unexpected liability. That liability stems from similar yet distinct employee protections: 1. the related and common employer doctrines, and 2. the risk that franchisees are recharacterized as employees.
What Is the “Related Employer” Doctrine?
Under both the LRA and the ESA, a franchisor can be found to be “related” to another employer, in this case its franchisee. If so, the franchisor may share liability for statutory protections owed to the franchisee’s employees, including:
- vacation pay;
- termination and severance pay; and
- collective bargaining obligations.
In short, a franchisor can technically be held liable for the statutory entitlements of its franchisees’ employees. Courts and tribunals conduct a complex assessment, but a central question is how much control the franchisor assumes over the franchisee’s business and its employees. Generally, the more control a franchisor takes over key aspects of the franchisee’s business, the more likely it is to be found a related employer.
What Is the “Common Employer” Doctrine at Common Law?
A franchisor can also be found to be a “common” employer at common law. This is similar to the related employer doctrine, but it can lead to much higher liability.
The difference often arises where employment contracts for franchisee employees do not validly limit entitlements to statutory minimums. In that case, the employees’ rights are governed by the common law, which is far more generous on termination than provincial statutes. If a franchisor is a common employer, it could face substantial payouts when a franchisee terminates an employee.
How Does the Fundamental Control Test Work?
Courts typically apply the “fundamental control test,” drawing on the indicia in York Condominium Corp., [1977] OLRB Rep. Oct. 645, and Downtown Eatery (1993) Ltd. v. Ontario, 2001 CanLII 8538 (ON CA). They consider whether the franchisor ultimately controls:
- how the franchisee’s employees perform their work;
- how employees are paid;
- how discipline is imposed; and
- the ability to hire and fire workers.
The perception of who the employer is, and the parties’ intentions about whether an employment relationship exists, are also important factors.
Can a Franchisee Be Found to Be the Franchisor’s Employee?
The second distinct area is a more recent development: in some cases, a franchisee themselves may be found to be an employee of the franchisor rather than an independent contractor. This is rare, but the Supreme Court of Canada recognized the possibility in Modern Cleaning Concept Inc. v. Comité paritaire de l’entretien d’édifices publics de la région de Québec, 2019 SCC 28.
Franchisors that try to limit their liability by tightly controlling the franchise agreement, including taking complete control over the financial risks and gains, may risk being identified as the franchisee’s employer. That would immediately trigger statutory employee entitlements and potentially common law protections, creating significant liability.
Modern Cleaning turned on a broad definition of “employee” in Quebec legislation. However, the ESA also has a broad definition of “employee” that is regularly interpreted liberally in favour of employees, so it is likely that the reasoning in Modern Cleaning could gain traction in Ontario. Since coming out, Modern Cleaning has been cited, albeit sparingly, in jurisdictions outside of Quebec.
Practical Tips for Franchisors
- Review how much control your franchise agreements and operations manuals impose over franchisee staffing, pay, and discipline.
- Ensure franchisee employment contracts validly limit entitlements to statutory minimums.
- Avoid presenting yourself to franchisee employees as their employer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a franchisor be liable for a franchisee’s employees in Ontario?
Yes. A franchisor can be found to be a related employer under the ESA and LRA, or a common employer at common law, depending on their level of control.
What is the difference between a related employer and a common employer?
Related employer liability concerns statutory entitlements. Common employer liability arises at common law and can lead to much higher termination payouts.
What is the fundamental control test?
It is a test examining whether the franchisor controls the franchisee’s work, pay, discipline, and hiring and firing, along with how the parties perceive the relationship.
Could a franchisee be treated as an employee of the franchisor?
Rarely, but yes. If the franchisor controls the financial risks and gains of the franchise, it risks being found the franchisee’s employer.
Get Legal Guidance on Franchise and Employment Law
The overlap between franchise and employment law can be complex, and the cost of getting it wrong can be high. At Szadurski Law, we help franchisors and businesses understand and manage employment liability. Learn more about our firm, or explore our practice areas and legal services. Contact us today to review your franchise structure.
Nothing in this blog should be construed as offering legal advice. The blog is for informational purposes only.